Generation 3 Generation 4 Arnold GOODLIFFE 1807-1888 married 1830 Ann Speed 1807-1895 |= | | Thomas (William) GOODLIFFE 1831-1889 married Ann STAFFORD   |= | Mary Ann GOODLIFFE 1833-1892 married 1860 William EATON   |= | Ellen (Helen) Elizabeth GOODLIFFE 1835-1872   |= | | Pickering GOODLIFFE 1836-1892 married 1865 Margaret MURPHY   |= | | Sarah GOODLIFFE 1839-1909 married 1867 William FROGGATT   |= | | | Frederick Arnold GOODLIFFE 1842-1909 married 1867 Elizabeth SWAIN   |= | Harriett Eliza GOODLIFFE 1844-1847   |= | | Edwin Daniel GOODLIFFE 1848-1909  married 1870 Elizabeth CLARKE |= Mary GOODLIFFE 1846-1855